June 8, 2023

Renewal Screening Checks

Every landlord knows that vacancies can harm their rental business. That’s why finding long-term tenants is crucial. Longer tenancies come with a stable, passive income and the peace of mind of knowing your rental is taken care of. 


So, it makes sense to want good tenants to stay on your property after their lease is over. However, simply renewing their rental agreement is not a great idea. 


When you rush into a lease renewal, you run the risk of facing issues such as late or missed rent, legal disputes, and evictions. A previous tenancy doesn’t guarantee that a renter will be on their best behavior moving forward. That’s why performing renewal screening checks is highly recommended. 


If you don’t know where to start, keep reading! In this article, we’ll dive into everything you should know about renewal screenings and how to conduct them.


Benefits of Renewal Screenings


The main goal of tenant screening is to ensure you ensure your renters are responsible and trustworthy. Renewal screening checks have the same purpose. Not screening current or past tenants before renewing their rental agreement can leave landlords vulnerable to liabilities. 


Your renters may go through changes during the course of their tenancy, so it’s best to treat them like you would any new renter and screen them thoroughly before signing anything. This will let you determine whether they’re worth keeping on your property. There are many other benefits to renewal screening checks, including:

One pair of hands typing on a silver laptop, another pair of hands filling out a document
  • Saving money. A renewal screening can help you avoid late and missed rent payments. It can also help you avoid spending money on things like urgent repairs or lawyers.


  • Improving the relationship with your tenants. Renewal screenings allow you to spot issues in your tenant’s finances, credit, and other aspects that may affect you as a landlord. Over time, communication and transparency between both parties can lead to happy and satisfied renters.


  • Reducing tenant turnover. With a lease renewal screening process, you can ensure tenants will remain responsible and reliable, reducing the tenant turnover rate and saving you from having to find new tenants.


  • Less risk of eviction. Evaluating a tenant’s financial status and behavior during the renewal process can help you identify potential issues before it’s too late and the only course of action is an eviction.


  • Reducing stress. With a renewal screening check, you’ll know your residents remain responsible and trustworthy and you won’t have to worry about the condition of your rental.


Conducting a Renewal Screening Check


Renewal screenings are not too different from new resident screenings. In fact, since you won’t need to gather as much information as the first time around, renewal checks are easier. Below are some key steps to follow to conduct a lease renewal screening.

Person sitting at their computer and making a phone call while taking notes

1. Review Their Rental History


In a normal screening process, you’d have to contact applicants’ former landlords to get a sense of what they’re like as renters. In this case, your experience with a tenant will help you determine whether they’re still a good fit for your rental. Ask yourself the following questions:


  • Did they always pay rent on time?
  • Did neighbors or other tenants ever complain about them?
  • Did they cause any issues during their tenancy?
  • Did they comply with the terms of the lease?


If the answers to these questions are not positive, then renewing their lease is not advisable.


2. Request Updated Financial Information


As a landlord, you want to ensure you’re renting your property to someone who can pay rent on time every month. A tenant’s income, employment status, and
credit score can change significantly over the course of the lease. That’s why you should check their current financial status.


3. Conduct a Property Inspection


Inspecting the property once a tenant’s lease has ended allows you to identify any damage or maintenance issues that need to be addressed. Furthermore, comparing notes on previous inspections will let you know if a tenant has stuck to the terms of the lease and kept the rental in good condition.

A property manager walking through a unit with a family of three

4. Review Their Criminal Background


Even if you think you know a renter very well, performing a criminal background and court history check is essential. If a tenant poses a potential risk to neighbors or other tenants, it’s best not to renew their lease.


5. Offer a Lease Renewal


Once you’ve conducted the renewal screening, you have to determine if renewing the lease is a good idea. If you decide to keep the tenant on your property, you should draft a new rental agreement. Make sure to update the terms, whether it’s the price of rent, length of the lease, or additional provisions. 


Once you have the new lease ready, talk to the tenant about the changes before signing it. 


Tips for Conducting Effective Renewal Screenings


A renewal screening check can be very beneficial to you as a landlord. However, some renters may think it’s an invasive process. To help you conduct renewal screenings smoothly, keep the next things in mind:

  • Follow the Fair Housing Act guidelines. Keep the process non-discriminatory and make renewal screenings a standard across all your leases. 


  • Disclose the renewal terms from the start. Let renters know this is a required practice in all your leases beforehand. This way, there’ll be no misunderstandings when it’s time for their renewal screening.
White printed document that says
  • Hire a professional. Tenant screening can be a time-consuming process. Luckily, you can hire a third-party professional to handle the process. At MTD Property Management, we know how to conduct effective tenant screenings and can help you ensure only the best tenants occupy your rental!


Bottom Line


Renewal screening checks are a must. They ensure your renters remain reliable and responsible, and keep you and your property protected from liabilities.


If you need help screening tenants, contact
MTD Property Management today! Our team of professional property managers will actively work to ensure we find the best renters for your rental.

Blog

By Donna Erf June 5, 2025
Have you explored U.S. property investment as a foreign buyer? Learn how to manage rentals, stay compliant, and maximize your returns abroad.
By Donna Erf June 3, 2025
Have you reminded tenants to report repairs promptly? Timely maintenance requests help preserve your property and boost tenant satisfaction.
By Donna Erf May 8, 2025
Key Takeaways Focus on Tenant Retention : Maintaining positive relationships with current tenants through responsive communication and quality maintenance can lead to long-term occupancy and reduced turnover costs. Maintain Property Appeal : Regular upkeep and improvements, such as landscaping and prompt repairs, enhance the property's attractiveness, encouraging both current and prospective tenants to choose and stay in your rental. Chicago Property Management Set Competitive Rental Prices : Researching local market rates ensures your rental pricing is attractive to potential tenants while maintaining profitability. Streamline the Leasing Process : Utilizing digital tools for applications and leases, and responding promptly to inquiries, can expedite tenant onboarding and reduce vacancy periods.Vacancy is one of the most costly issues a rental property owner can face. Every day your unit sits empty is a day of lost income. It also means increased operational expenses, additional marketing efforts, and the possibility of property deterioration. At MTD Property Management , we know that reducing vacancy rates is not just about finding tenants quickly. It’s about keeping good tenants happy, pricing your units appropriately, and maintaining your property so that it remains attractive and competitive in the market. Here are actionable strategies to minimize vacancy in your rental properties. Keep reading to learn more! Keep Your Current Tenants Happy One of the most effective ways to avoid vacancies is to focus on tenant retention. It costs far less to keep an existing tenant than to find a new one. When you maintain a good relationship with your tenants, they’re more likely to stay long-term. That means fewer gaps between leases, fewer marketing expenses, and fewer maintenance costs associated with preparing a unit for a new renter. All of this helps maintain stronger cash flow . Start by responding to tenant concerns promptly and respectfully. Provide quality maintenance and conduct occasional property inspections to ensure everything remains in good condition.
More Posts